← Back to blog

Gift Guide

Giftster Alternative: A Fair Comparison for Any Shop

Published 24 October 2026 · Updated 5 November 2026

Giftster is a good app, and for a private family group it is hard to beat. If you are looking for an alternative, it is usually for one of three reasons: you want to save things from any shop with one tap, you want a gift to be claimed with a tap on Dibs so nobody doubles up, or you want birthdays and Secret Santa in the same place as the list. This page is a fair comparison. Giftster's own website would not load for us when we checked on 24 October 2026, so the Giftster facts below come from its App Store and AlternativeTo listings, checked on 21 October 2026.

Browse Christmas gift ideas

Top 30 Gifts for Christmas

  1. Gozney Arc Lite | Compact Pizza & Outdoor Oven1

    Gozney Arc Lite | Compact Pizza & Outdoor Oven

    A compact gas pizza oven that T3 and Tom's Guide praise for fast heat-up and restaurant-style pizza, a big-ticket Christmas gift for anyone who loves cooking ou

    £349.99Gozney

  2. Mystical Eye Makeup Bag3

    Mystical Eye Makeup Bag

    A hand embroidered velvet make up bag that Woman & Home picked for its 2026 beauty gift guide; a keepsake that suits someone who already has the products (chris

    £54Elizabeth Scarlett

  3. Mini Perfume Gift Set | Charlotte Tilbury5

    Mini Perfume Gift Set | Charlotte Tilbury

    A trio of travel-size perfumes, in Woman & Home's Christmas beauty guide (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 4: fragrance and bath time).

    £48Charlotte Tilbury

  4. Gold Lust Collection7

    Gold Lust Collection

    Oribe's Gold Lust repair set, a Woman & Home Christmas pick for a hair-care splurge (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 5: hair care for the hair they have).

    £115Oribe

  5. Glisten & Glow Rosehip Routine9

    Glisten & Glow Rosehip Routine

    Woman & Home picks this rosehip skincare routine as a gentle, useful Christmas set (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 1: skincare that is gentle and useful).

    £45Neal's Yard Remedies

  6. Compass Beanie Dark Rust11

    Compass Beanie Dark Rust

    A soft ribbed beanie in recycled yarn, picked by HELLO! as a stocking filler under £25 and an easy, safe gift for him (for christmas-gifts-for-him, section 5: s

    £24.95Passenger

  7. Bibliophile Erasers (Erasers)13

    Bibliophile Erasers (Erasers)

    Four rubbers decorated as classic novel covers, a small and witty stocking filler for a keen reader.

    £14.99Abrams & Chronicle Books

  8. D'Addario PW-GBMT-01 Multi-Tool for Guitar and Bass15

    D'Addario PW-GBMT-01 Multi-Tool for Guitar and Bass

    A pocket-sized 10-in-1 tool with hex keys and screwdrivers that a guitarist can keep in the gig bag; Guitar World lists it as a stocking filler.

    £16.99Andertons Music Co

  9. Clinique for Men Sonic Purifying Cleansing Brush | Mankind17

    Clinique for Men Sonic Purifying Cleansing Brush | Mankind

    FashionBeans includes this sonic cleansing brush in its men's grooming gifts, a step up from a basic face wash for a daily routine.

    £79Mankind

  10. Stage Creator Kit 3-in-1 for Content | Belkin UK19

    Stage Creator Kit 3-in-1 for Content | Belkin UK

    HELLO! recommends this tripod, phone mount and wireless mic kit for a teenager who wants to make videos.

    £129.99Belkin

  11. Makeup Organiser Makeup & Beauty Stackers21

    Makeup Organiser Makeup & Beauty Stackers

    HELLO! suggests this stackable organiser for a teen with a growing makeup collection.

    £55Stackers

  12. Apple AirPods Pro 3 with MagSafe Charging Case (USB-C), White23

    Apple AirPods Pro 3 with MagSafe Charging Case (USB-C), White

    Which? picked these noise cancelling earbuds as a top gift for teens, and John Lewis shoppers rate them 4.8 out of 5.

    £219.00John Lewis

  13. Kapten & Son Card Holder, All Black27

    Kapten & Son Card Holder, All Black

    A slim card holder for six cards with a zip pocket for coins, made from recycled materials.

    £34.90Kapten & Son

  14. Commissionit Pet Oil Portrait, Hand Painted From Your Photos29

    Commissionit Pet Oil Portrait, Hand Painted From Your Photos

    Hand painted oil portrait of one pet, up to A4, free UK delivery.

    £495Commissionit

  1. Westman Atelier Petite Petal Edition (Worth £87.00) | CultBeauty2

    Westman Atelier Petite Petal Edition (Worth £87.00) | CultBeauty

    Marie Claire UK beauty director picks this four piece lip and cheek set in the bestselling Petal pink as a gift to hand over boxed; for christmas-beauty-gifts,

    £70Cult Beauty

  2. PowerCapsule | Magnetic powerbank for smartphones4

    PowerCapsule | Magnetic powerbank for smartphones

    HELLO! picked it among its useful Christmas gifts for him: a slim magnetic power bank that clips to the back of a phone, for brother-gift-ideas section 2 (gadge

    £49.99Twelve South

  3. Elemis Melt The Day Away Skincare Gift Set6

    Elemis Melt The Day Away Skincare Gift Set

    A cleanser and balm set for winding down, in Woman & Home's Christmas beauty guide (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 1: skincare that is gentle and useful).

    £55John Lewis

  4. Inner Beauty Hydrating Facial Collection (Worth £121) | ESPA8

    Inner Beauty Hydrating Facial Collection (Worth £121) | ESPA

    A hydrating facial set from ESPA, chosen by Woman & Home for its Christmas beauty guide (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 1: skincare that is gentle and useful).

    £80ESPA

  5. Rest Day Contour Sleep Mask10

    Rest Day Contour Sleep Mask

    A silk contoured sleep mask, picked by Woman & Home as a Christmas beauty gift (christmas-beauty-gifts, section 7: presenting it well).

    £73Slip

  6. MV Siren™ Muse Disc Chain Bracelet | Monica Vinader12

    MV Siren™ Muse Disc Chain Bracelet | Monica Vinader

    Which? picks it as engraved jewellery she will wear for years: the gold vermeil disc can be etched with her initials (for christmas-gifts-for-her section 4, dau

    £85Monica Vinader

  7. Ernie Ball 10 ft Braided Guitar Cable in Black with Straight Jack to Angled Jack14

    Ernie Ball 10 ft Braided Guitar Cable in Black with Straight Jack to Angled Jack

    MusicRadar loves these tangle-resistant braided cables; a sturdy, noise-shielded replacement that any guitarist or bassist will use at every gig.

    £24.99Andertons

  8. 54% Dark chocolate flakes | Blend16

    54% Dark chocolate flakes | Blend

    Grazia picks Knoops' 54% dark hot chocolate flakes as a stocking filler; a cosy, easy treat for anyone who likes proper hot chocolate. For stocking-filler-ideas

    £13.50Knoops

  9. The Total Transformation Set18

    The Total Transformation Set

    A five-step skincare set with cleanser, exfoliant, vitamin C and retinal serums, moisturiser and a beauty bag, picked by Woman & Home as a gift she would secret

    £99.00Liberty London

  10. Junior Supercar Taster20

    Junior Supercar Taster

    An experience instead of more stuff: HELLO! lists this junior supercar taster for teens who love cars.

    £69Find Me A Gift

  11. ghd Platinum+® Hair Straightener, Black22

    ghd Platinum+® Hair Straightener, Black

    Which? featured these straighteners as a premium gift for her, and John Lewis shoppers rate them 4.5 from over 3,800 reviews.

    £186.00John Lewis

  12. Ivy Desk Plant Pet24

    Ivy Desk Plant Pet

    The plant pet that tells you when it's thirsty.

    $98.99Plantsio

    HintDrop perk: 8% off
  13. Kapten & Son Water Bottle, Steel Black, 0.75L26

    Kapten & Son Water Bottle, Steel Black, 0.75L

    A leak proof stainless steel bottle that keeps drinks hot or cold, swapping out a lot of single use bottles.

    £34.90Kapten & Son

  14. Commissionit House or Wedding Venue Portrait, Painted From a Photo28

    Commissionit House or Wedding Venue Portrait, Painted From a Photo

    Watercolour or acrylic portrait of a home or venue, up to A4, free UK delivery.

    £395Commissionit

  15. Teapigs On The Go Bundle, Tea and Travel Cup30

    Teapigs On The Go Bundle, Tea and Travel Cup

    Tea temples, a taster pack, a travel tin and a leak proof travel cup.

    £29.99Teapigs

    HintDrop perk: 20% off

What Giftster does well

Giftster is built around the extended family. You invite people into a private group and everyone keeps a list. Its App Store listing says gifts can be marked as reserved or purchased, and the person whose list it is cannot see that status, so the surprise survives. There are apps for iPhone, iPad and Android as well as the website.

It also has a Secret Santa draw for groups of three or more, with exclusions, and it shows upcoming family birthdays. The App Store lists it as free with no in app purchases and rated 4.8 out of 5 from about 17,000 ratings. That is a solid record, and we will not pretend otherwise.

Where people look for something different

The most common reason is the shopping side. A wishlist is only useful if adding to it takes seconds. Giftster has a browser button called Add to Giftster for saving from any store while you shop. Some people want the same speed from a phone, straight from the Share sheet in whatever app they are browsing, and from a laptop in a single click.

The second reason is who you are sharing with. Giftster is group first, so people join your family group. If you would rather send one link to a friend, a partner or an aunt who will never install anything, a plain shared list is simpler.

How HintDrop differs

HintDrop is an all year gifting app for friends and family. You save an idea from any shop by tapping Share on your phone, using the free browser extension on Chrome, Edge, Firefox or Safari, or pasting a link. The name and picture come with it, so a book from one shop, a jumper from another and a candle from a third sit on one list.

You send the list as a link. The people buying tap Dibs, so nobody doubles up. It also does birthday reminders, group gifts where everyone chips in, and a free Secret Santa tool with exclusions where the organiser cannot see who drew whom. It is free on iPhone, Android and the web.

Where Giftster is the better choice

Be honest about what you need. Giftster supports child accounts that other family members can help manage, and it has a longer track record as a private family home. If one extended family wants one tidy private group with reserve marking and a draw, Giftster may suit you better than we would.

We are the better fit when the list spans many shops, when the people buying are friends as well as family, and when you want to add things in the moment from your phone without opening another app first.

How to switch, or use both

You do not have to move everything. Start a list for this Christmas, add five things you actually want, and send the link to the person who always asks what you would like. If they use it, it works. If they prefer your family's Giftster group, keep that.

Do not copy a whole list across in one go. Pick the things you still want, because lists get stale. Our guide to Christmas list ideas is a good way to refresh one while you are at it.

Which one should you pick?

Choose Giftster for a private family group with child accounts. Choose HintDrop for a list across many shops that anyone can open from a link, with claiming, birthdays and Secret Santa in the same app. For a wider comparison that includes Elfster and Amazon Wish List, read our best wishlist apps guide.

Giftster Alternative: A Fair Comparison for Any Shop pin

Save this guide for later

Pin it now, come back when the birthday creeps up.

Save to Pinterest

Frequently asked questions

Is Giftster free?

Its App Store listing shows it as free with no in app purchases, checked on 21 October 2026. Check the current listing before you rely on that.

Can I save gifts from any shop on Giftster?

Giftster has a browser button called Add to Giftster for saving items from any store, according to its App Store listing. We also save from any shop, using the phone Share sheet, a browser extension or a pasted link.

Can the person I am buying for see what has been reserved?

On Giftster the list owner cannot see the reserved or purchased status. With us, people tap Dibs and the surprise stays with the buyers.

Does Giftster have Secret Santa?

Yes, for groups of three or more with exclusions. We also have a free Secret Santa tool with exclusions.

Do I need to make an account for every relative?

Not to look at a shared list link on ours. Check each app's own page for what viewers need to do.

Ready to actually find something?

Browse Christmas gift ideas