← Back to blog

Gift Guide

Elfster Alternative: A Fair Free Secret Santa Draw

Published October 24, 2026 · Updated November 6, 2026

Elfster is the name most people know for Secret Santa, and it is good at it. If you want an alternative, the usual reasons are wanting a draw that stays private even from the organiser, a wishlist that takes items from any shop, and a tool you can use for birthdays all year rather than once in December. We have a free Secret Santa tool that does exactly that. This is a fair comparison, with Elfster's facts taken from elfster.com on 24 October 2026 and its App Store listing on 21 October 2026.

Browse Christmas gifts under 30

Top 30 Gifts for Christmas gifts under 30

  1. Plant Pot Bookends1

    Plant Pot Bookends

    Wirecutter's pick for book lovers: half-pot bookends that hold a small succulent, for the reader who has everything (book-gift-ideas, section 3: bookends).

    $30The Morgan Library & Museum Shop

  2. Canvas Tote Bag - Book Club3

    Canvas Tote Bag - Book Club

    Rolling Stone picks this illustrated tote for readers; roomy enough for a stack of library books, and under $25. For book-gift-ideas, section 3: book accessorie

    $22.40Rifle Paper Co.

  3. Get Closer Conversation Game: Table Talk - Table Talk5

    Get Closer Conversation Game: Table Talk - Table Talk

    CNN Underscored picks this deck of conversation prompts for getting to know friends better; a card game for couples that turns a night in into a proper catch up

    $20Intelligent Change

  4. Uncommon Goods | Desk Yoga Card Deck | Desk Yoga7

    Uncommon Goods | Desk Yoga Card Deck | Desk Yoga

    Food Network lists it among its teacher gifts; 52 quick stretches and breathing practices a teacher can do between lessons.

    $20Uncommon Goods

  5. ER20XS | High Fidelity Earplugs - Standard9

    ER20XS | High Fidelity Earplugs - Standard

    Reusable earplugs made for musicians that cut loudness evenly so music still sounds natural, a thoughtful gift for anyone who plays or goes to gigs (for stockin

    $24.99Etymotic

  6. Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count11

    Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count

    PureWow recommends this tin of bakery cookies as a treat teachers will happily share in the staff room.

    $28Milk Bar

  7. Glow Mist Rosewater Revitalizing Hand Sanitizer - Touchland | Ulta Beauty13

    Glow Mist Rosewater Revitalizing Hand Sanitizer - Touchland | Ulta Beauty

    A pretty, rose-scented hand mist that CNN Underscored recommends for teachers who wash and sanitise their hands all day; a small treat under $20.

    $16.00Ulta Beauty

  8. Biodance Bio Collagen-Real Deep Mask | Soko Glam15

    Biodance Bio Collagen-Real Deep Mask | Soko Glam

    CNN Underscored includes this in its teen girl gifts; an overnight collagen mask for a low-cost skincare treat.

    $19.0Soko Glam

  9. Kepler Pen17

    Kepler Pen

    A neat, well-made desk pen at a small price, picked by CNN Underscored as a practical thank you for a teacher.

    $10Craighill

  10. Ms. Rachel Tonie19

    Ms. Rachel Tonie

    A 45-minute screen-free audio figure of songs from Ms. Rachel that sits on a Toniebox, which a parent tester at Yahoo/AOL named her best new toy of 2025.

    $19.99Tonies

  11. Lindt Lindor Assorted Milk Chocolate Truffles Large Bag - World Market21

    Lindt Lindor Assorted Milk Chocolate Truffles Large Bag - World Market

    Named in NBC Select's teacher gifts for a sweet tooth; a big shareable bag of truffles that is a safe, modest thank you.

    $13.29World Market

  12. Men's Hiker Quarter Midweight Hiking Socks23

    Men's Hiker Quarter Midweight Hiking Socks

    CNN Underscored picks these cushioned merino hiking socks for dads; they come with a lifetime warranty, so they suit a dad who walks a lot.

    $23.00Darn Tough

  13. Chef Collection Skillets25

    Chef Collection Skillets

    CNN Underscored recommends this Lodge skillet; a durable, affordable pan for a dad who loves cooking steaks or breakfasts.

    $19.90Lodge

  1. Porcelain Mug - Book Club2

    Porcelain Mug - Book Club

    Gold-handled porcelain mug printed with classic book spines; a small, well made gift for a reader. For book-gift-ideas, section 3: book accessories.

    $24Rifle Paper Co.

  2. Best Smelling Moisturizing Natural Hand Cream – SALT & STONE4

    Best Smelling Moisturizing Natural Hand Cream – SALT & STONE

    InsideHook picks it as a stocking filler that feels like a small luxury; a fast-absorbing hand cream with seaweed extract and vitamin B3. For christmas-gifts-fo

    $20Salt & Stone

  3. Joy Laforme Spring Terrace 1000 Piece Puzzle6

    Joy Laforme Spring Terrace 1000 Piece Puzzle

    Featured in CNN Underscored's gifts under $25; a bright, illustrated 1,000 piece puzzle for anyone who likes a slow evening in (for christmas-gifts-for-friends,

    $19.99Galison

  4. Dog Poop Bag Holder | Wild One8

    Dog Poop Bag Holder | Wild One

    A neat silicone bag holder that clips to the lead, a small, well designed stocking filler for anyone who walks a dog; featured by The Strategist. For gifts-for-

    $9Wild One

  5. Fender Security Strap Locks and Buttons Set - Chrome10

    Fender Security Strap Locks and Buttons Set - Chrome

    Featured by Guitar World in its gifts under $50; keeps a guitar safely on its strap on stage.

    $14.84Sweetwater

  6. Uncommon Goods | Mason Jar Indoor Herb Garden | Hydroponic Grow Kit12

    Uncommon Goods | Mason Jar Indoor Herb Garden | Hydroponic Grow Kit

    A small hydroponic grow kit from PureWow's teacher list that brightens a desk or classroom windowsill.

    $20Uncommon Goods

  7. Bento Box Lunch Containers for Adults & Kids (3 Pack, 39 oz)14

    Bento Box Lunch Containers for Adults & Kids (3 Pack, 39 oz)

    CNN Underscored lists these bento containers in its fitness gifts for anyone who meal preps; a practical stocking filler for the gym-goer.

    $19.99Fit Strong & Healthy

  8. Marble Shaving Bowl | Handcrafted, Heat-Retaining | Supply16

    Marble Shaving Bowl | Handcrafted, Heat-Retaining | Supply

    CNN Underscored lists it among its tested grooming gifts; a heat-retaining marble bowl that makes a wet shave feel more of a ritual.

    $24Supply

  9. Birth Month Mini Embroidered Journal - January18

    Birth Month Mini Embroidered Journal - January

    CNN Underscored's girlfriend guide suggests this mini hardcover journal, embroidered with her birth-month flower, for a girlfriend with a journaling or sketchin

    $26.0Rifle Paper Co.

  10. Kalastyle Swedish Dream Gnome Soap Swedish Pine | Boston General Store20

    Kalastyle Swedish Dream Gnome Soap Swedish Pine | Boston General Store

    A small stocking-filler bar of classic Swedish pine soap, which Cup of Jo recommends for dads who like a woodsy scent.

    $12.00Boston General Store

  11. The Pigeon Won't Count to 10!22

    The Pigeon Won't Count to 10!

    A funny counting book from Mo Willems that makes a cheap, much-loved stocking gift for small readers; picked by Good Housekeeping for toddlers.

    $9.31Bookshop.org

  12. Balancing & Stacking Tree 10440 | DUPLO® | Buy online at the Official LEGO® Shop US24

    Balancing & Stacking Tree 10440 | DUPLO® | Buy online at the Official LEGO® Shop US

    A Good Housekeeping Toy Award winner: toddlers stack and balance the pieces while building fine motor skills, and it fits easily in a stocking.

    $13.99LEGO

  13. gold under eye patches for dark circles by grace & stella - grace & stella26

    gold under eye patches for dark circles by grace & stella - grace & stella

    A small, affordable pampering treat that NBC Select recommended for mum, good for stockings and Secret Santa.

    $26.00Grace & Stella

  14. 50 Must-Read Books 1000-Piece Puzzle | Ridley's Games30

    50 Must-Read Books 1000-Piece Puzzle | Ridley's Games

    A 1000-piece jigsaw of a bookshelf of classics, picked by CNN Underscored for readers who like a screen-free evening (for christmas-gift-ideas and book-gift-ide

    $24.99Ridley's Games

What Elfster does well

Elfster began as a Secret Santa site. Its page says wishlists are free with no premium plan, lists are private by default and are shared by link. It also links to generators for Secret Santa, White Elephant, Yankee Swap and Dirty Santa, and to office and online gift exchange pages.

Its App Store listing says it handles groups from 3 to 300 or more, with exclusions so couples do not draw each other, and a rating of 4.9 out of 5 from about 332,000 ratings. For a big draw, that is a strong track record.

What to check before you choose

Elfster's own page says its browser extension adds items from Amazon, Etsy, Target or any online store with one click. The page does not say how purchases are marked, so we cannot tell you whether the list owner can see what has been bought. Ask the group before you rely on it. Its App Store listing is also tagged with Advertising, which is worth knowing if you care.

A fair Secret Santa draw needs three things

First, exclusions, so partners and housemates are not matched. Second, a draw the organiser cannot peek at, otherwise the organiser knows everything and the fun leaks out. Third, a budget stated up front so nobody spends five times more than their match. Everything else is nice to have.

Set the rules in the group chat before the draw, not after. A short note with the budget, the date and whether gifts should be useful or funny avoids most awkwardness.

How HintDrop does it

HintDrop's Secret Santa tool is free. The organiser sets exclusions, and cannot see who drew whom. People can reveal privately, and each person can have a list on HintDrop with ideas saved from any shop through the phone Share sheet, the free browser extension or a pasted link.

When your match is a mystery, a list makes the gift easy. When people tap Dibs on a list, nobody doubles up. The same app also does birthday reminders and group gifts where everyone chips in, so it stays useful after December.

Where Elfster is the better choice

If you are running a very large office draw, or you need White Elephant or Yankee Swap style exchanges, Elfster lists those as features and has a long record with large groups. For a small group of friends or family that wants a private draw plus lists from any shop, we are a good fit. You can find our Secret Santa tool at hintdrop.app/secret-santa.

Choosing a budget and gifts

A budget of 10 to 30 in your own currency suits most groups. Useful beats funny for people you barely know, such as a good notebook, a nice candle or a tin of something tasty. Our family Secret Santa ideas and Secret Santa gift ideas guides have lots of examples you can browse in the shop.

Frequently asked questions

Is Elfster free?

Elfster's own page says its wishlists are free forever with no premium plan or credit card required, checked on 24 October 2026.

Can I use Elfster for a large group?

Its App Store listing says it handles groups from 3 to 300 or more.

Does our Secret Santa let the organiser see who drew whom?

No. The organiser sets the exclusions but cannot see the draw.

Can I add gifts from any shop to a wishlist?

Yes with us, using the Share sheet on your phone, the free browser extension, or a pasted link. Elfster also says its extension works with any online store.

What budget should we pick for Secret Santa?

10 to 30 in your own currency works for most groups. Agree it before the draw.

Ready to actually find something?

Browse Christmas gifts under 30